Meandering Thoughts from Pastor Brehms
A Meandering of my thoughts about PVA and Adventist Education in general.
This is the first time I have chosen to speak out on this forum. I have spent the last six and a half years of my life working with Platte Valley Academy in the capacity of district pastor. I sent my son Justin there, and he graduated in "04". My daughter Heather just finished her junior year and looks forward to returning her senior year "07". I have watched enrollment decline over the past six and a half years. There has been genuine concern over this decline on the part of the board upon which I have been a member. Currently I have accepted a call, and by the time this is posted to the blog will have already left for my new post in Northern California.
PVA is not where I graduated from. I attended Monterey Bay Academy in Watsonville. It was one of the best four years of my teenage life, and it was strict. nothing like the strictness of today. Today we are extremely lax in comparison. Movie Theatre attendance was grounds for being expelled. and there was nothing more than intramural sports. I don't think things were so bad back then. Yes, the discipline was much more strict than in many Adventist homes, but is it possible that this is a shame on our Adventist homes, and not the school.
In my academy days many of the kids referred to "the prison" I never thought of it that way, because my home was far more strict than the academy. That is why the pen of inspiration warns parents to be careful who their children play with, and to make sure that the standards of parenting are the same. It disturbs me that the discussion even came up about video games. My stand is, and has been, if it has nothing to do with enhancing academics, then it doesn't belong on campus. Computers are to assist young people in research, and to help them understand the high tech world they are going to be entering. The games themselves, many of them innocuous are for the most part a colossal waste of time. I have observed my daughter spend hours in front of a game boy brought into the home by my son-in-law. I mean hours and hours. Granted she gets good grades, and she does a great deal of reading. But, she is like myself, sedentary in her habits which contributes to an unhealthy outcome.
I was, and remain antagonistic to competitive sports in our schools. I have heard all the arguments about learning sportsmanship, and learning to be gracious in loss and victory, sorry, it's so much trash as far as I am concerned. Competitive sports by their very nature are a part of Satan's kingdom. Now don't rise up and say I said they were Satanic. I DID NOT SAY THAT! However, in Satan's system there is always a loser. For you to win in Satan's system someone else has to lose. Well you say, that's life, and so it is, but to nurture and encourage the competitive spirit is antagonistic to God's system in which you compete with yourself. You strive continually to be better than you were before, not to best someone else, or to defeat another individual, but to constantly be doing whatever it is you do better than you did it before. music, physical exercise, work. Whatever it is. That is God's system. Which system are we stressing at our academies, which we have declared are dedicated to the training of young people of service to God? "Training The Youth of Today To Be The Leaders of Tomorrow!"
I recognize that the unregenerate, unconverted heart is selfish, and is always striving for supremacy. That is the natural course of our sinful condition. Competition will be present whether we want it or not. It will take the form of: our band is better than their band, or our choir is better than their choir, and the story will go on and on. However, the thrust of academic activities should still be to be the best you can be despite a grade curve, or what someone else is doing, and the question is which system are we emphasizing in our schools. How in the world of competitive sports ever made into our schools with the plethora of statements from the pen of inspiration that is totally and completely and without equivocation antagonistic to it, is beyond me. There has been some artful twisting of the Spirit of Prophecy to get that one accomplished.
The video games are just an extension of the competitive sports deal with the exception that is does nothing to physically invigorate you spiritually, or physically, and in fact evidence would suggest that it makes some young people withdraw socially. Maybe your kid won't react that way, just like not every person has a gene that makes them an alcoholic with very little exposure to alcohol, but if even one kid is adversely effected, is it worth the risk.
I know this piece is meandering as it has touched on what many will think are unrelated issues, but they are related. What are we sending our kids to academy for? Why are we spending $10,000.00 a year in tuition? if not for something better than the world offers. An Oasis from worldly influences. Will the worldly influences come? Yes. Do we need to invite them, receive them, and go out and hunt for them to come? Absolutely NOT!
One more thought about the competitive sports issue. Since the emphasis on sports has come into our educational system. Music programs nationwide have suffered. Money that once went to support scholarships at universities like Southwestern Adventist University now go for sports scholarships. It used to be that if you were a sat lead chair, or were in the select choir you were eligible for scholarships. Not anymore! Now that money is channeled to sports scholarships, and for what? not one of those kids with those scholarships will ever play professional ball. they will never make a living at it. Recruiters won't even come and see them play in our little one horse arenas, and basically Sports are just not academic, it does nothing to enhance mental discipline which is what education is all about. The best that can be said about it is that it keeps you physically fit, and there is numerous other things that could keep you equally fit. We have traded our silk purse for a sow ear, and no one seems to get it.
Last but no least. I never opposed outright video games on campus. I did oppose and still oppose video games on students personal computers in their rooms. It has put the deans in a position of policing something that is virtually impossible to police. It force them to invade the privacy of the students computer to be sure that games that have absolutely no place in a Christian's possession are not there.
Had the suggestion been to create a student center in the administration building where students with qualifying grades could come for some down time and play games on a school owned machine, controlled by the staff, game boy, any of the programs. That would have been far better than what we got.
The board voted for the academy staff to come up with a policy regarding video games. They (the faculty) did. They said they didn't want them on campus. The Board then interpreted that vote in November to be a vote to force the acceptance of video games in the dorms, and since the staff and faculty had not come up with a policy (which did not include not having video games) they had lost their right to call the shots. I was one of those board members who absolutely did not believe that we had voted to force the staff to make a policy. I was as amazed at the next board meeting when we were informed that the vote was a done deal, and that it could only be revisited by a 2/3rds majority vote. "Like that was going to happen".
Well it is no longer my responsibility. I love PVA, my heart is there, my children have attended there. I respect the staff and teachers. They have done an outstanding job training my children. It is my opinion that with both Gary Russell and Jim Goodchild which I know to be honest, moral and deeply devout men, have been micro managed from Topeka. This must stop. PVA administration must have the ability to make decisions regarding policy that as long as it does not violate the educational code of the General Conference, Mid-America Union, or the Kansas-Nebraska Conference, and have the unconditional backing of the conference administration and the academy board. Neither the conference officials, or the board members with the exception of a very few are on campus enough to know what is really going on, and therefore policy issues regarding academic standards, leisure activity and discipline should be left to the Administration of the academy without interference from conference or board.
When each young person and their parent registers for school, they sign that they have read the handbook and will comply with the provisions of that handbook, and any subsequent provisions that may be adopted. What I have observed is a few whiny brat kids that have run to mommy and daddy with "poor me, their being mean to me, and they won't let me do this or that", and mommy and daddy instead of saying, "That's tough, life doesn't always go your way, and you need to buck up and do what you signed at the beginning of the year that you would do. Comply with rules of this institution, not come and then try to change the rules because you don't like them." Rather parents have themselves become whiny and complained and at times verbally abused the faculty and staff because their kids were whiners. My grandmother (who raised me) might not always have agreed with what the teachers or staff did, but I never knew it. There was always a united front between my grandmother and the teachers. If I caught it at school, I double caught it at home. To bad it's not that way anymore.
I will continue to pray for Platte Valley Academy. I still believe it is the best kept secret in North America. Please, PLEASE, PLEASE don't let it die because of micro management from above. May God help us all to this end, and sorry I rambled.
Pastor Randy Brehms
Former Pastor: Aurora, Grand Island, and Shelton/Platte Valley Academy

9 Comments:
Pastor Brehms,
Thank you for your post. I enjoyed reading it and agreed with you on most points. PVA is the best kept secret in North America! However, I must wholeheartedly disagree with you on the issue of competitive sports. You say that sompetitive sports only challenge you physically and do not improve you mentally? I played competitive sports while in high school, and I have benefited from those experiences in the mental aspect much more than the physical aspect as I have made my way through college and now life. Sports teaches you disicipline, setting goals, and knowing you can make it no matter what the obstacle is in front of you. It teaches you to push yourself to limits you may not have thought possible. In order to physically enhance yourself, you must first overcome the mental obstacle. Sports has taught me to be strong and push through things that weren't always so pleasent or things I thought I was not capable of achieving. Music is also important, but God gives us all talents. Some music, some athletic, some both. It's the beauty of life, no one person is the same, or holds the same talents, but let's not hold certain talents above others. I hope you see where I am coming from and will reconsider your obviously strong opposition to competitive sports in our schools. God Bless.
I FULLY agree with Pastor Brehms. Especially on the sports issue. I have watched the way sports are handled at our school and I must say that after Mr. Johnson left there was no reason to even show up at rec. The only thing that happened at rec was Basketball or another competative sport, and you were pressured to play.
If yo want to be challenged and learn "disicipline, setting goals, and knowing you can make it no matter what the obstacle is in front of you" go take a Martial Arts class. A real Martial Arts class does not create compitition but works mainly on the mind... for a good idea on what I mean look at omahamartialarts.com to see what a real "Sports education" should teach you. I fully believe that Competitive sports should be banned because they teach contempt and pride. but this will not happen ever so i dont push the issue I just avoid sports on every occation I can and take Martial Arts two to three times a week.
Mike J. Campbell
-Class of 2007 at Millard North Public School-
Um just bc Pastor Brehms doesn't like to or cannot play sports is no reason to say they should be banned.Calling academy kids whiny brats is not going to solve anything either.Lets try to be mature about this, shall we?
Pastor Brehms you make it sound like sports are a sin to play. I'm sorry you and your family aren't good at sports but some for some of us it's the only thing we know. Some of us aren't good at music and stuff like that so at least we can show our talents throught the things that we love the most. Since we're on the subject of you making sports sound like a sin isn't a sin to be a lesbian or something like that? And one of your kids is one of the kids that complains about the rules and stuff and whine about what the dean tells her and I know this for a fact so don't point fingers at other parents and thier kids when your kid is one of the winey brats
Sports is not a sin, it also is not academic as far as a discipline. Granted it does teach one to make and acheive goals, it does teach discipline, that is not denied. It is the competativeness that I struggle with. I win, you loose. For me to be the best I must defeat someone else, or many other persons.
Is this a part of life. Yes, we compete for jobs, for grades. But the basic system is still flawed by the fact that in order for someone to win, someone else must loose where when one strives to be better each time they do something then the competition is with oneself, hence there is no loosers.
It is a fact that I excelled at musical arts, and because of my weight never excelled at sports. I remember vividly being among the last chosen on a team, and having the captain of that team groan because "Do we have to have him, we'll loose for sure". I saw others rediculed because they could not, or were not good at physical sports. That pain was very real, and many times those kids suffered silently.
Yes, you may excell at sports, and you may learn many good things with regard to social adaptation, and loosing gracefully, or even being magnanimous in victory, but the fact remains the same that it is not an academic discipline. One's IQ does not increase because of participation in sports, while the arts have been proven in studies to increase IQ.
Sports is not a sin, but it doesn't belong in Seventh-day Adventist Schools that are based on the bible and the Spirit of Prophecy which roundly condemns competative sports. And yes my kids have been whiny brats, the difference is that they got no sympathy from either mom or dad, and we didn't call the faculty and administration and run them through the wringer. that is the difference. Some of my favorite kids at PVA are good at sports, and basketball, what I have said is not aimed at them personally, and my thoughts reflect my opinion only. And because I believe in what I have said I am willing to sign my posts.
Pastor Brehms
May I remind everyone that, though the discussion is a disagreeable subject, anyone who is not bold enough to write their name on a post is sipmly a COWARD, this goes for any post; and I may add, that if we are all TRULY Seventh-day Adventists, we would read and FOLLOW the Spirit of Prophecy as a GUIDELINE to our lives. No one can debate that ALL of our school systems have declined in membership. ALL of our schools have increased the circulation of Movies that would have been considered obscene in years past. And ALL of our schools play competative sports, though most originally did not. My point is, this crippling is not simply contained to Platte Valley Academy, alough I wish it were. If you were truly a SDA Christian, you would stand for your beliefs as former teachers and students, not simply write them from your ANONYMOUS username on a computer.
Nothing can be done, if we won't do it. God can only bless a movement, not a stagnation.
I guess I'm "sipmly a COWARD". Judge not, lest ye be judged. Thank you very much.
-Anonymous.
These are some of the oldest, and most visceral debates in the generational conversation about Adventist academies. I am a PVA grad ('89) and while I respectfully disagree with Pastor Brehms, I think that none of these are the primary issues facing the boarding school concept in this day and age.
First and foremost, the academy should be an institution of academic excellence. Far more focus should be placed on the quantity and quality of the classes offered, instructors available, interaction with colleges and universities in our system, and ensuring that graduates are prepared for either further education or participation and training in useful trades.
Equally important should be the focus on teaching and training Adventist values, doctrine, and culture. In my travels, I've come to realize that "the Church" is a diverse and interesting organization. It encompasses many different views on non-doctrinal issues like sports, music, dress, and entertainment. But the underlying principles remain fairly consistent, in spite of our differing philosophies about some of the specifics.
I've started a group for PVA on facebook. I encourage anyone who has ever been affiliated with the academy to stop by sometime.
Peace,
--K. Fitzgerald Stewart, PVA '89
Randy, thanks for your post. I went to an Adventist gradeschool, and then to a Catholic high school, where I got my start with computers partly from teaching myself to write my own clone of some of the early video games. As the parent of a 20 year old who spent a few years in our small Adventist church schools, I have had some encounters with the school boards.
Another area of worldly influence in our schools is the drama clubs. I was in more than one school play as a kid. But our school plays were directly based on Bible stories, I remember having some part in a play about the image of King Nebuchadnezer, and Daniel and his friends in the furnace. I don't remember what part I played, but I remember it was interesting. The plays I sometimes see our kids doing now have scarecely more relation to the Bible than the use of some Biblical names.
I think it can be easily proven that while there are a lot of possible downsides with computers, especially those hooked to the unfiltered internet, I'm hesitant to remove the incredible opportunities that computers present to the kids. While I'd want to be a parent who supports the school board, if my child showed skill at writing his own video games, I'd be irked if that activity were prohibited. And yet technology isn't the answer to everything. Those who think technology can replace the one-on-one audience that Christ used, they are just as wrong as the luddite.
Technology and communications are presenting so many challenges for us today in raising our kids. Somehow we need to help our kids to understand the value of time, and the need to employ as much as possible in a productive pursuit, while also learning the balance of relaxing in ways that don't dishonor our creator.
I am alarmed by trends to make our schools fact mills just like the worldly teach to test schools. The emphasis on the practical needs to be maintained. I hope it isn't too late for our schools, but for now I remain committed to home schooling as the best way to be sure about my child's schooling.
Read more at my blog post today: http://www.bobsgear.com/x/RoA2AQ
Post a Comment
<< Home